📍 1140 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305
📞 (718) 816-6516   •   🕒 Mon-Thu 11am-10:30pm • Fri-Sat 11am-11:30pm • Sunday Closed
Staten Island Pizzeria • Trattoria Italiana

Tony’s Brick Oven

Taste The Difference. Where The Good Eats Are.

Taking over Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza is Sal, bringing a strong background from the seafood industry. Known locally as the “Calamari Kid,” Sal built his reputation in the fish business before stepping away 25 years ago. Now, he returns to hands-on business ownership with a focus on maintaining what works while upgrading the operation where it counts..

📞 Call 718-816-6516 View Menu Preview
Tony's Brick Oven flyer

Since 1997

True Traditional Italian Pizzeria

Tony’s Brick Oven of Staten Island opened in 1997 and has become a local landmark of the Rosebank neighborhood. The restaurant practices old school Italian recipes and style to create authentic pizza and Italian cuisine with a hidden-gem New York feel.

Originally from Mola Di Bari, Italy, Angelo Panzini brought recipes and techniques in pizza making and Italian cooking from his home country. Having worked in pizzerias since coming from overseas, Angelo has been mastering the pizza trade for over 40 years.

From mopping floors in Brooklyn pizzerias, to making pizzas, to eventually opening his own pizzeria in Staten Island, Angelo continued a family style of pizza and Italian cooking that customers came to know and trust.

Opened in 1997 and became a local landmark in Rosebank.
Old school Italian recipes with Brooklyn-style pizza roots.
Family owned and operated for over 25 years and counting.

Menu Preview

Tony’s Brick Oven Menu

Menu preview pages are shown using only the uploaded menu files.

Pizza Menu

Pizza menu

Appetizers, Salads, Pasta & Baked Dinners

Appetizers, salads, pasta and baked dinners menu

Heroes, Sandwiches, Wraps & Entrees

Heroes, sandwiches, wraps and entrees menu

Gallery

Food & Dining Room Photos

A small preview using only the images you attached.

Brick oven slice

Brick Oven Slice

Shrimp pasta

Shrimp Pasta

Dining room

Dining Room

Restaurant flyer

Restaurant Flyer

Community Update

New Ownership, Same Neighborhood Feel

Staten Island, NY — Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza, a cornerstone of the Rosebank and North Shore community, is entering a new chapter as longtime owner Angelo retires after more than 30 years in the pizza business.

For decades, Angelo built Tony’s into a trusted neighborhood destination known for consistent quality, familiar faces, and a true community atmosphere. His retirement marks the end of an era, but the foundation he created remains intact.

Taking over Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza is Sal, bringing a strong background from the seafood industry. Known locally as the “Calamari Kid,” Sal built his reputation in the fish business before stepping away 25 years ago. Now, he returns to hands-on business ownership with a focus on maintaining what works while upgrading the operation where it counts.

Family-Driven Operation Continues

  • ✓Santino, Sal’s son, will be working in the restaurant throughout the summer.
  • ✓Multiple family members will be involved in daily operations.
  • ✓Andres, a familiar face to longtime customers, will remain on staff.

Modern Upgrades for a Better Experience

  • ✓New POS system to streamline ordering and service.
  • ✓TVs inside the restaurant for an enhanced dine-in experience.
  • ✓Expanded online ordering and delivery platform availability.
Social
Instagram • TikTok • Facebook
Direct Online Ordering +
Uber Eats, DoorDash, Seamless
Looking Ahead: Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza remains committed to delivering the same quality food and neighborhood experience that built its reputation — now supported by modern systems and expanded accessibility. This transition isn’t about changing what Tony’s is; it’s about making sure it continues to serve the community for years to come.

Catering

Catering & Party Trays

The uploaded catering flyer is used directly as the visual reference for this section.

Great for family gatherings, office lunches, birthdays, and local events. Call Tony’s Brick Oven to discuss tray options, heroes, and party packages.

Call For Catering Catering Page
Tony's Brick Oven catering flyer

Brick Oven Pizza

Taste the Best Brick Oven Pizza in Staten Island

Authentic Italian Pizzas Made Fresh Daily

Located at 1140 Bay St, in the heart of Rosebank, Staten Island, Tony’s Brick Oven is your destination for authentic, wood-fired pizza. The custom-built brick oven, reaching a scorching 900 degrees, delivers perfectly cooked pizzas with a delicate, slightly charred crust in just about 3 minutes.

Tony’s prides itself on freshness and quality. The dough is made in-house daily, the sauce is crafted from hand-crushed tomatoes, and the mozzarella is pulled fresh every day. From pizzas to pastas, hot sandwiches, and classic Italian dinners, every bite is packed with quality ingredients and classic Italian flavor.

Brick oven pizza slice
Tony's Brick Oven dining room

Dine In Atmosphere

Comfortable Neighborhood Dining

The dining room photo gives the site a real local feel while keeping the design clean, simple, and focused on the restaurant.

🍕 Pizza
Brick oven, pan, Sicilian, slices and more.
🍝 Italian Classics
Pasta, heroes, wraps, entrees and catering trays.

Contact

Visit Tony’s Brick Oven

Call, visit, or view the menu preview above.

Tony's Brick Oven logo

📍 1140 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305

📞 (718) 816-6516

Mon-Thu: 11:00am - 10:30pm • Fri-Sat: 11:00am - 11:30pm • Sunday: Closed

🛒 Direct Online Ordering Available

Call Restaurant Order Online View Menu