About Us

At Tony's Brick Oven, enjoy a brand new upgrading dining room area and brick counter. Same Quality that you have become accustumed to is what you will get at Tony's Brick Oven. Try our authentic Wood Burning pizza. Sicilian Specials and various dishes from our kitchen.

What people says...

A long trusted staple of the Rosebank community and the only Pizzeria on Bay worth visiting. Slices are big and the specialty slices (buffalo& chicken Alfredo) are worth it too. Solid seafood combos (Shrimp Oreganata) and Paninis for a healthier choice. Very clean restaurant.

I have been enjoying Tony's pizza for a few years and this is straight forward my #1 pizza place in NYC! We come here often, sometimes take-out, some times dine-in. Everything here is delicious, my favorites are: buffalo pizza, margarita pizza, vodka pizza, and the buffalo chicken roll .

I have been enjoying Tony's pizza for a few years and this is straight forward my #1 pizza place in NYC! We come here often, sometimes take-out, some times dine-in. Everything here is delicious, my favorites are: buffalo pizza, margarita pizza, vodka pizza, and the buffalo chicken roll .

Up from DC for work with a couple other people and we wanted some NY pizza. Tony's Brick Oven was perfect! Tons of choices, pizza was awesome, polite staff, and very clean and cozy place to eat in! Highly recommend!

Hours & Information

1140 Bay Street
Staten Island, NY 10305

Monday - Thursday : 11.00 am - 11.00 pm Friday & Saturday : 11.00 am - 12:00 am Sunday : CLOSED